Kerala Rising: From Exporting People to Exporting Ideas · Page 282 of 353

KERALA RISING · FROM EXPORTING PEOPLE TO EXPORTING IDEAS

KERALA RISING · FROM EXPORTING PEOPLE TO EXPORTING IDEAS
21. The hardest questions,
answered
Each program chapter answered the objections
to that program. This chapter answers the
harder ones; the objections a Chief Secretary or
a finance minister raises not to a program but to
the whole idea of building the institution at all.
The previous two chapters raised the ceiling,
naming what this could become at its most
ambitious. Intellectual honesty now requires the
opposite move: lowering it to the hardest objections
a sceptic can put, because a vision that cannot
survive a Chief Secretary’s scepticism is not worth
the paper it is printed on. The per-program
objections in Part Two are real but local. The
objections that decide whether this happens are
raised one level up, about the enterprise itself. They
deserve direct answers, and the answers are
stronger when the objection is stated at its most
forceful rather than softened.
‘Why an institution? Just procure each program from a
vendor.’
This is the most important objection, because it is
the default. The answer is the entire economic
argument of the book in one line: procuring seven
programs from vendors means paying seven times
282